Robert Frost a truly American poet
08/11/05 14:06
Frost was truly an American poet, because he was, well, American, at least after his ancestors cleared the New England land of the true inhabitants, the Native Americans. So there is always a dark side to the white farmer American. Living in the midwest and in California I have heard some stories of how Christian, white settlers would go out after midnight and kill Indian men, women and children, to clear the land of 'Indians' and gain the land for themselves. Behind the protestant, white American farmer facade is the skeleton in the closet. Not only did someone in the extended family in each generation go crazy, estimates of up to a half of the young women were raped in the sense of sexual incest that was practiced on the farms. But, startling as it seems, the same was found to be true for European farmers as well.
Author's note: After writing the above intuitively I have just researched and found out that Robert Frost had an ancestor, Charles Frost, living in Eliot, Main, who invited some Native Americans over for a feast and when they had stacked their arms he killed a number of them. They ones who escaped took revenge and killed him on his way from church.
Whose woods are these? My thesis confirmed! In Robert Frost by Jeffrey Meyers. Robert Frost apparently waved a gun at his wife in his farmer days.
Whose woods these are I think I know.
His house is in the village though;
He will not see me stopping here
To see his woods fill up with snow.
The woods are lovely, dark and deep.
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.
We left out two verses about the horse which make it nice and quaint, and maybe take the sting out of the poem. The truth is that this strikes one as rather sinister. The owner in town owns the woods. Why? How? Stolen from Native Americans of course. These beautiful woods belonged to the people who lived in them not that long ago and did not cut them down or build farms of them, until the whites came.
The threat then of the owner seeing the person stopping to see the woods fill up with snow. This is the really ominous line, and marks this as good poetry because it is a subtle contrast with the peacefulness of the snowy scene in winter. The poet makes the point that someone owns these woods. Thus we realize that the white civilization has come in and taken over natural beauty. The rightful inhabitants before the whites did not proclaim individual ownership. Individual ownership makes possible the exploitation of nature and is in our day the cause of nature's downfall, and maybe our own as a human species.
All is not well in nature even and must be covered over by the white.
Promises to keep? Another ominous sign of the dark side. Modern white man lives by appointments in time. You promise someone ahead of time that you will be with them at a certain hour and so you limit your ability to journey freely enough to be with what is happening in the moment.
Many have seen the "miles to go before I sleep" as eventual death. Thus the traveler stopping by the woods senses the eventual quiet of dead, which happens to everyone, but he is not ready yet. He has purpose yet to want to stay alive. This implies that the owner of the woods is death itself, nature that gives life but also takes it all away. A natural woods has decay all about it while a woods in modern Europe is almost always cleaned up by foresters. There is no past in a typical European woods. They do not even let the trees get old before they cut them down. When they leave a patch, then they revere it as something mysterious from the past, rather than natural and therefore to be preferred.
Apparently Frost wrote this poem spontaneously at the end of a long night trying to write a 'big' poem. This came when his ego intentions were down and a natural flow just happened, the individual replicating history.
We draw parallels because we can see that Frost as poet, even in modern American society, was not safe from evil himself, or in his ancestry. Thus, while rural America was disappearing, Frost tried to go back to the land and farm a farm. Yet his readers were mostly in the city, and so loved his rural poetry. It doesn't matter that city readers have mostly escaped from rural America because they hated the village life they had to grow up in as much to limiting. Ah, the American village! It is also in the poem. The owner of nature lives there. So does death as owner of your body.
The American nightmare is to be truly in nature like the Native American, at one with the land. The transplanted American is really a European immigrant destroyer who had nothing in the old country and so fled to the new to exploit the land, using European values, rather than integrate with the land as modern ecologists would have us do.
It's truly a sinister poem, this one, but you won't hear this in the typical American college, literature class where this poem is highly revered. We may revere our poets for their poetry, but for their personalities? Almost never!